“I Call It… SONG-TAKING!”
Tuesday, December 30th, 2008This Christmas I received Coldplay’s “Viva La Vida/Prospekt’s March” from my friend. Right now it’s in a tie for Best Present between The Dark Knight and Season 4 of House. I’m not a fan of their early work, although they’ve had one or two songs that I’ve appreciated. Viva La Vida, however, really works for me. I don’t know if it’s the composition or the production or what have you… But it scratches me right where I itch.
The reason I bring this up is because Joe Satriani recently filed suit against them for allegedly “plagiarizing significant material” from his song “If I Could Fly” for their title track.
If you’d like, you can compare. Here’s Coldplay’s “Viva La Vida“.
And here’s Satriani’s “If I Could Fly”:
Having listened to them both, I was worried I might give Coldplay a break just because I’m more familiar with their work, and(now) consider myself a fan. But honestly? Satriani’s is a better composition in some ways. However, even I think Joe’s just being a drama-queen here.
Aside from the obvious tempo difference, there is only one(Verse? Chorus?) “part” of If I Could Fly that bears a similarity to Viva La Vida, and even then, careful attention shows that although the similar segment starts out… well, similar, Viva La Vida’s quickly goes into something a little more rapid(as if trying to fit in as many notes as possible), while Satriani’s follows longer, more sustained notes, and THEN goes into something wild and different, a crazy, long-ass guitar solo. It threw me for a loop at first, but after a while, it’s becoming more and more obvious how much the compositions differ. The two are only the “same” song for all of 1 or 2 seconds, before departing back onto individual paths. Can it then, be considered a “significant” example of theft?
(As you’ve undoubtedly figured out, I’m awful with musical terminology. The only high school class I ever failed was Guitar, and that was because I could never get my head around “cleffs” and “bridges” and such. So perhaps I’m the wrong person to be writing this article. I’m sorry, I know this makes it difficult to get my point across. If only my musically-inclined former roommate were here to straighten out my gibberish…)
I’m willing to admit to being naive here, and maybe Chris Martin and co. decided to be all Vanilla Ice about it. But I see a lot of effort put into both songs, and I find it hard to believe that Coldplay would get lazy with their title track. Besides, in case Joe didn’t notice, there was a Sum 41 song that came out a while back that sounded suspiciously like Colplay’s “The Scientist”. I seriously doubt that they would start deliberately ripping off popular and renowned guitarists after that.
I like both of those songs. But they’re TWO SONGS. Regardless of which one is “better”, or made by “more talented” musicians, I don’t think Satriani has any case here. At all. Which is why I’m sure he’ll win his suit. A good number of Daily Show episodes reveal just how brainless and corrupt the American Justice System is, a snake trying to find food to survive by choking to death on its own tail.
END OF LINE
~A.H.



